| Since 1996 | Four Star | Draft | 2024 | |||||
| Order | Round 1 | Round 3 | Round 5 | |||||
| Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | |||||
| Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | |||||
| Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | |||||
| Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | |||||
| Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | |||||
| Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | |||||
| Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | |||||
| Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | |||||
| Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | |||||
| Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | |||||
| Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | |||||
| Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | |||||
| Round 2 | Round 4 | Round 6 | ||||||
| Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | Shit-Throwing Monkeys | |||||
| Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | Playtex Warriors | |||||
| Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | Little Yankees Simp | |||||
| Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | Harrison County Harem | |||||
| Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | Sandusky's Shower Kittens | |||||
| Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | Vanderberg Venom | |||||
| Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | Ringless Marinos | |||||
| Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | Show Me Your TD's | |||||
| Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | Owosso Thunder | |||||
| Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | Pepsi Patriots | |||||
| Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | Schaumburg Ghost Monkeys | |||||
| Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | Katina's Genital Wart II | |||||